Pittsburgh Pirates Lead Cincinnati Reds 5-1 in Head-to-Head Matchups (2026)

MLB1-5-0 ATS (16.67%)Updated 21 days ago

The Cincinnati Reds are 1-5 against the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2026 in head-to-head matchups, going 1-5-0 ATS (16.67% cover rate) with -75.16% ROI. Games average 9.8 total points. Closing lines from DraftKings, FanDuel, and BetMGM, graded against official MLB box scores.

See methodology.

Reds vs Pirates Betting Record — 2026

Against the Spread

1-5-0

Win %

16.67%

ROI

-75.16%

Units

-4.5

Moneyline

1-5-0

Win %

16.67%

ROI

-70.41%

Units

-4.2

Over Rate

4-2-0

Win %

66.67%

ROI

+25.6%

Units

+1.5

From the Other Side — Pirates vs Reds

Against the Spread

5-1-0

Win %

83.33%

ROI

+84.25%

Units

+5.1

Moneyline

5-1-0

Win %

83.33%

ROI

+45.58%

Units

+2.7

Over Rate

4-2-0

Win %

66.67%

ROI

+25.6%

Units

+1.5

Venue Splits

Reds Home

1-2-0 ATS

33.33% • -50.33%

1-2-0 ML (33.33%)

Pirates Home

3-0-0 ATS

100% • +119.5%

3-0-0 ML (100%)

Scoring Averages

Reds

2.7

PPG

7.2

allowed

Total

9.8

Avg

games

Pirates

7.2

PPG

2.7

allowed

Recent Matchups (2026)

Date	Matchup	Score	Spread	ATS	ML	O/U
05/032026-05-03	Reds @ Pirates	L 1-0	-1.5	✗	L	U
05/022026-05-02	Reds @ Pirates	L 17-7	-1.5	✗	L	O
05/012026-05-01	Reds @ Pirates	L 9-1	-1.5	✗	L	O
04/012026-04-01	Pirates @ Reds	L 3-8	-1.5	✗	L	O
03/312026-03-31	Pirates @ Reds	L 3-8	-1.5	✗	L	O
03/302026-03-30	Pirates @ Reds	W 2-0	-1.5	✓	W	U

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates 2026 record?

The Cincinnati Reds are 1-5 against the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2026 in head-to-head matchups.

What is the Cincinnati Reds ATS record vs the Pittsburgh Pirates?

The Cincinnati Reds are 1-5-0 against the spread vs the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2026 on DraftKings, with -75.16% ROI.

Do Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates games go over or under?

Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates games average 9.8 total points in 2026. The Over has hit 66.67% of the time.

More Reds Matchups

vs Cubs

vs Brewers

vs Cardinals

See from Pirates perspective

Head-to-head betting record for Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates in the 2026 season on LineTerminal. The Reds are 1-5 straight up against the Pirates and 1-5-0 against the spread (16.67% cover rate, -75.16% ROI) on DraftKings. Data sourced from DraftKings closing lines. Updated daily after games are graded. Past performance does not guarantee future results.