Toronto Blue Jays Lead Pittsburgh Pirates 11-4 in Head-to-Head Matchups

MLB6-9-0 ATS (40%)

The Pittsburgh Pirates are 4-11 against the Toronto Blue Jays in head-to-head matchups, going 6-9-0 ATS (40% cover rate) with -30.92% ROI. Games average 7.1 total points. Closing lines from DraftKings, FanDuel, and BetMGM, graded against official MLB box scores.

See methodology.

Pirates vs Blue Jays Betting Record

Against the Spread
6-9-0
Win %
40%
ROI
-30.92%
Units
-4.6
Moneyline
4-11-0
Win %
26.67%
ROI
-41.15%
Units
-6.2
Over Rate
5-7-3
Win %
41.67%
ROI
-20.69%
Units
-2.5

From the Other Side — Blue Jays vs Pirates

Against the Spread
9-6-0
Win %
60%
ROI
+22.64%
Units
+3.4
Moneyline
11-4-0
Win %
73.33%
ROI
+21.27%
Units
+3.2
Over Rate
5-7-3
Win %
41.67%
ROI
-20.69%
Units
-2.5

Venue Splits

Pirates Home
3-6-0 ATS
33.33% • -39.94%
2-7-0 ML (22.22%)
Blue Jays Home
3-3-0 ATS
50% • +3.4%
4-2-0 ML (66.67%)

Scoring Averages

Pirates
2.7
PPG
4.5
allowed
Total
7.1
Avg
15
games
Blue Jays
4.5
PPG
2.7
allowed

Recent Matchups

DateScoreATSMLO/U
05/24W 1-4WU
05/23L 5-2LU
05/22L 6-2LP
08/20W 2-1WU
08/19L 3-7LO
08/18W 5-2WP
06/02L 5-4LO
06/01W 1-8WO
05/31L 5-3LP
05/07L 1-10LO
05/06L 2-8LO
05/05L 0-4LU
09/04L 3-4LU
09/03L 1-4LU
09/02L 0-4LU

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays all-time record?
The Pittsburgh Pirates are 4-11 against the Toronto Blue Jays in head-to-head matchups.
What is the Pittsburgh Pirates ATS record vs the Toronto Blue Jays?
The Pittsburgh Pirates are 6-9-0 against the spread vs the Toronto Blue Jays on DraftKings, with -30.92% ROI.
Do Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays games go over or under?
Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays games average 7.1 total points. The Over has hit 41.67% of the time.

More Pirates Matchups

Head-to-head betting record for Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays on LineTerminal. The Pirates are 4-11 straight up against the Blue Jays and 6-9-0 against the spread (40% cover rate, -30.92% ROI) on DraftKings. Data sourced from DraftKings closing lines. Updated daily after games are graded. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

LineTerminal provides sports data and analytics for informational and entertainment purposes only. LineTerminal does not accept, place, or facilitate bets or wagers of any kind. Odds data is sourced from third-party providers and may not reflect exact lines at every sportsbook. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Sports betting involves risk — never wager more than you can afford to lose.

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-MY-RESET (National Problem Gambling Helpline) or visit ncpgambling.org. Must be 21+ in most jurisdictions. Please gamble responsibly.

© 2026 LineTerminal LLC. All rights reserved.