NHL Prop Leaderboards

Top 2025-26 NHL player prop performers ranked by over hit rate. Sort by ROI, games, or average actual. 681 players, 86,847 graded props.

Season

#	Player	Team
1	Jonas Brodin	Wild	44-20	67.7%	+17.47%	2.1
2	Neal Pionk	Jets	14-9	60.9%	+18.35%	1.7
3	Thomas Harley	Stars	46-29	60.5%	+8.03%	2.1
4	Martin Fehervary	Capitals	47-32	59.5%	+2.37%	2.1
5	Brandt Clarke	Kings	43-30	58.9%	+7.87%	2.4
6	Adam Larsson	Kraken	47-33	58.8%	+0.69%	2
7	Thomas Chabot	Senators	34-21	58.6%	+7.21%	2
8	Travis Sanheim	Flyers	52-37	57.8%	+2.03%	1.9
9	Mattias Samuelsson	Sabres	50-37	57.5%	+1.83%	2
10	Mario Ferraro	Sharks	47-35	57.3%	+1.91%	1.8
11	Ben Chiarot	Wings	44-33	57.1%	-1.1%	1.9
12	Zach Whitecloud	Golden Knights	16-12	57.1%	+5.99%	2.1
13	Matt Roy	Capitals	43-33	56.6%	-5.06%	1.8
14	Darnell Nurse	Oilers	49-38	56.3%	-4.25%	2
15	Mike Matheson	Canadiens	52-39	55.9%	+3.07%	2.1
16	Timothy Liljegren	Sharks	24-17	55.8%	-1.15%	1.8
17	Ryan Pulock	Islanders	40-31	55.6%	-5.12%	1.9
18	Brett Pesce		20-15	55.6%	-2.56%	2.1
19	Cam York	Flyers	46-36	55.4%	-6.58%	2
20	Shea Theodore	Golden Knights	11-9	55%	-0.27%	2.1
21	Jake Sanderson	Senators	39-29	54.9%	-4.56%	1.9
22	Andrew Peeke	Bruins	34-28	54.8%	-3.68%	1.9
23	Dylan Samberg	Jets	34-28	54.8%	-3.51%	1.8
24	Brayden McNabb	Golden Knights	41-33	54.7%	-0.51%	2.2
25	MacKenzie Weegar	Mammoth	44-37	54.3%	-0.04%	2.1
26	Moritz Seider	Wings	44-37	54.3%	+3.23%	2.2
27	Charlie McAvoy	Bruins	40-33	54.1%	-3.98%	1.9
28	Colton Parayko	Blues	41-35	53.9%	+3.31%	2.2
29	Rasmus Sandin	Capitals	22-19	53.7%	+3.94%	1.7
30	Brock Faber	Wild	40-34	53.3%	-4.61%	1.9
31	Josh Morrissey	Jets	25-22	53.2%	+2.12%	1.7
32	Marcus Pettersson	Canucks	38-34	52.8%	-4.14%	1.7
33	Esa Lindell	Stars	46-42	52.3%	-7.45%	2.2
34	Miro Heiskanen	Stars	39-36	52%	-2.32%	1.7
35	Erik Cernak	Lightning	14-13	51.9%	-1.51%	1.9
36	Noah Dobson	Canadiens	44-41	51.8%	-6.29%	2.4
37	Braden Schneider	Rangers	39-37	51.3%	-9.74%	1.7
38	Rasmus Andersson	Golden Knights	47-45	51.1%	-12.32%	1.8
39	Lane Hutson	Canadiens	26-25	51%	-4.93%	1.7
40	Connor Murphy	Oilers	36-35	50.7%	-7.25%	1.8
41	Jared Spurgeon	Wild	44-42	50%	-11.98%	1.7
42	Alex Vlasic	Blackhawks	29-29	50%	-8.22%	1.6
43	Brandon Carlo	Maple Leafs	27-27	50%	-11.56%	1.8
44	Vincent Desharnais	Sharks	25-24	50%	-8.13%	1.6
45	Ryan McDonagh	Lightning	21-20	50%	-1.28%	1.7
46	Sean Durzi	Mammoth	21-21	50%	-11.31%	1.7
47	Conor Timmins	Sabres	15-15	50%	-3.92%	2.1
48	Jake McCabe	Maple Leafs	39-40	49.4%	-2.91%	2.4
49	Dante Fabbro	Blue Jackets	32-33	49.2%	-9.94%	1.7
50	Morgan Rielly	Maple Leafs	28-30	48.3%	-6.66%	1.5
51	Simon Edvinsson	Wings	32-34	47.8%	-18.99%	2
52	Alexandre Carrier	Canadiens	41-45	47.7%	-9.09%	2.2
53	John Carlson	Ducks	20-22	47.6%	-5.03%	1.5
54	Nick Seeler	Flyers	40-45	47.1%	-14.5%	1.8
55	Cale Makar	Avalanche	37-41	46.8%	-6.54%	1.6
56	Tyler Myers	Canucks	27-30	46.6%	-12.13%	1.8
57	Ian Cole	Mammoth	40-47	46%	-17.24%	1.9
58	Mattias Ekholm	Oilers	23-27	46%	-12.86%	1.6
59	Jackson LaCombe	Ducks	38-45	45.8%	-16.7%	1.6
60	Brett Kulak	Avalanche	11-13	45.8%	-10.29%	1.7
61	Jacob Bernard-Docker	Wings	11-12	45.8%	-11.31%	1.6
62	Jakob Chychrun	Capitals	11-13	45.8%	-7.21%	1.7
63	Justin Faulk	Blues	26-31	45.6%	-11.48%	1.6
64	Matthew Schaefer	Islanders	10-12	45.5%	-8.93%	1.4
65	Roman Josi	Predators	31-36	44.9%	-12.04%	1.5
66	Ryan Lindgren	Kraken	25-31	43.9%	-16.12%	1.6
67	Pavel Mintyukov	Ducks	13-16	43.3%	-12.98%	1.4
68	Mikey Anderson	Kings	22-29	43.1%	-16.07%	1.6
69	Jamie Oleksiak	Kraken	18-24	42.9%	-19.32%	1.4
70	Jeremy Lauzon	Golden Knights	9-12	42.9%	-15.43%	1.5
71	Jake Middleton	Wild	26-35	42.6%	-21.05%	1.6
72	Adam Pelech	Islanders	23-31	42.6%	-19.58%	1.4
73	Radko Gudas	Ducks	20-27	41.7%	-24.51%	1.6
74	Erik Gudbranson	Blue Jackets	10-14	41.7%	-16.51%	1.5
75	Adam Fox	Rangers	13-19	40.6%	-22.4%	1.3
76	Simon Benoit	Maple Leafs	21-30	40.4%	-21.17%	1.6
77	Ivan Provorov	Blue Jackets	26-39	40%	-23.42%	1.6
78	Parker Wotherspoon	Penguins	12-18	40%	-17.62%	1.4
79	Jake Walman	Oilers	22-35	37.9%	-29.92%	1.6
80	Noah Hanifin	Golden Knights	14-23	37.8%	-24.6%	1.3
81	Jaccob Slavin	Hurricanes	13-21	37.1%	-22.04%	1.4
82	Artem Zub	Senators	24-41	36.9%	-32.93%	1.4
83	Sean Walker	Hurricanes	12-19	36.4%	-20.39%	1.4
84	Trevor van Riemsdyk	Capitals	9-16	36%	-29.97%	1.3
85	Mikhail Sergachev	Mammoth	26-47	35.6%	-34.81%	1.6
86	Philip Broberg	Blues	14-25	35%	-30.88%	1.5
87	Tyler Kleven	Senators	7-13	35%	-33.61%	1.1
88	Joel Edmundson	Kings	7-13	35%	-34.29%	1.3
89	Aaron Ekblad	Panthers	7-13	35%	-29.26%	1.2
90	Jacob Trouba	Ducks	31-61	33.7%	-34.99%	1.8
91	Vladislav Gavrikov	Rangers	13-26	33.3%	-38.67%	1.3
92	Denton Mateychuk		7-13	33.3%	-30.37%	1.2
93	Zach Werenski	Blue Jackets	9-20	31%	-39.65%	1.2
94	Connor Clifton	Penguins	11-24	30.6%	-39.25%	1.4
95	Rasmus Ristolainen	Flyers	9-21	30%	-38.9%	1.4
96	Hampus Lindholm	Bruins	8-19	29.6%	-40.74%	1.4
97	Devon Toews	Avalanche	5-15	25%	-44.05%	1.3

97 players with 5+ games

Rankings based on historical closing lines from DraftKings, FanDuel, and BetMGM, graded against official NHL box scores. ROI calculated on flat $100 bets. Updated daily.