Indianapolis Colts

Indianapolis Colts9-8-0 ATS · 9-8-0 ML · 2023-24

NFLAFC • AFC South

The Indianapolis Colts went 9-8-0 straight up, 9-8-0 ATS (52.94% cover rate), 11-6-0 O/U (64.71% over rate) in 2023-24, returning +1.17% ROI on flat $100 bets at closing odds. Closing lines from DraftKings, FanDuel, and BetMGM, graded against official NFL box scores.

See methodology.

Indianapolis Colts Betting Record — 2023-24

Against the Spread
9-8-0
Win%
52.94%
ROI
+1.17%
Units
+0.2
Moneyline
9-8-0
Win%
52.94%
ROI
+8.75%
Units
+1.5
Over Rate
11-6-0
Win%
64.71%
ROI
+23.4%
Units
+4.0

Colts Monthly Performance

+1.2%9-8 · +0.2u
+27.3%
-24%
+92%
-23.6%
-100%
Sep
2-1
Oct
2-3
Nov
3-0
Dec
2-3
Jan
0-1

Colts Home / Away Splits

Home
ATS
4-5-0-15.14%
ML
4-5-0-19.76%
O/U
7-2-0+48.69%
Away
ATS
5-3-0+19.53%
ML
5-3-0+40.83%
O/U
4-4-0-5.04%

Colts as Favorite / Underdog

As Favorite
ATS
5-1-0+59.65%
ML
6-0-0+75.29%
As Underdog
ATS
4-7-0-30.73%
ML
3-8-0-27.54%

Betting Against the Colts

What happens when you fade the Colts and bet on their opponent every game?

Fade Against the Spread
8-9-0
Win%
47.06%
ROI
-9.28%
Units
-1.6
Fade Moneyline
8-9-0
Win%
47.06%
ROI
-22.09%
Units
-3.8

Colts Recent Games

DateOpponentScoreATSMLO/U
2024-01-06vs TexansL 19-23LU
2023-12-31vs RaidersW 23-20WO
2023-12-24@ FalconsL 29-10LU
2023-12-16vs SteelersW 30-13WO
2023-12-10@ BengalsL 34-14LO
2023-12-03@ TitansW 28-31WO
2023-11-26vs BuccaneersW 27-20WO
2023-11-12@ PatriotsW 6-10WU
2023-11-05@ PanthersW 13-27WU
2023-10-29vs SaintsL 27-38LO
View full schedule

Colts Head-to-Head Matchups

AFC South Standings

MoneylineATSOver/Under
#TeamRecordWin%ROIRecordWin%ROIRecordWin%ROI
1HOU11-8-057.89%+26.06%10-9-052.63%+1.85%7-11-138.89%-26.07%
2IND9-8-052.94%+8.75%9-8-052.94%+1.17%11-6-064.71%+23.4%
3JAX9-8-052.94%-4.32%9-8-052.94%+1.25%8-9-047.06%-10.19%
4TEN6-11-035.29%+6.01%7-9-143.75%-15.96%6-11-035.29%-32.75%

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Indianapolis Colts record against the spread?
The Indianapolis Colts were 9-8-0 against the spread in 2023-24 on DraftKings, with a 52.94% cover rate and +1.17% ROI.
What is the Indianapolis Colts home and away ATS record?
At home, the Indianapolis Colts were 4-5-0 ATS (-15.14% ROI). On the road, they were 5-3-0 ATS (+19.53% ROI).
How did the Indianapolis Colts performed as favorites vs underdogs ATS?
As favorites, the Indianapolis Colts were 5-1-0 ATS (83.33% cover rate). As underdogs, they were 4-7-0 ATS (36.36% cover rate).
What is the Indianapolis Colts moneyline record?
The Indianapolis Colts were 9-8-0 straight up (moneyline) in 2023-24, with a 52.94% win rate and +8.75% ROI on DraftKings.

Indianapolis Colts Betting Record & ATS Analysis

The Indianapolis Colts were 9-8-0 against the spread in 2023-24 on DraftKings, covering at a 52.94% rate with a +1.17% return on investment for bettors. Their straight-up moneyline record was 9-8-0 (52.94% win rate). Games involving the Colts went Over at a 64.71% rate.

At home, the Colts were 4-5-0 ATS (-15.14% ROI). On the road, they were 5-3-0 ATS (+19.53% ROI). As a favorite, Colts covered at 83.33%. As an underdog, they covered at 36.36%.

Data sourced from DraftKings closing lines. Updated daily after games are graded. Past performance does not guarantee future results. LineTerminal offers advanced system-building tools to research Indianapolis Colts betting trends across 80+ filters and 5+ years of data.

LineTerminal

AI-powered betting intelligence for NBA, WNBA, NHL, MLB, NFL, NCAAB, and NCAAF.

LineTerminal provides sports data and analytics for informational and entertainment purposes only. LineTerminal does not accept, place, or facilitate bets or wagers of any kind. Odds data is sourced from third-party providers and may not reflect exact lines at every sportsbook. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Sports betting involves risk — never wager more than you can afford to lose.

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-MY-RESET (National Problem Gambling Helpline) or visit ncpgambling.org. Must be 21+ in most jurisdictions. Please gamble responsibly.

© 2026 LineTerminal LLC. All rights reserved.