James Madison Dukes Lead Marshall Thundering Herd 2-1 in Head-to-Head Matchups

NCAAF2-1-0 ATS (66.67%)Updated November 8, 2025

The Marshall Thundering Herd are 1-2 against the James Madison Dukes in head-to-head matchups, going 2-1-0 ATS (66.67% cover rate) with +28.72% ROI. Games average 41.7 total points. Closing lines from DraftKings, FanDuel, and BetMGM, graded against official NCAAF box scores.

See methodology.

Thundering Herd vs Dukes Betting Record

Against the Spread

2-1-0

Win %

66.67%

ROI

+28.72%

Units

+0.9

Moneyline

1-2-0

Win %

33.33%

ROI

+31.67%

Units

+0.9

Over Rate

1-2-0

Win %

33.33%

ROI

-36.9%

Units

-1.1

From the Other Side — Dukes vs Thundering Herd

Against the Spread

1-2-0

Win %

33.33%

ROI

-36.9%

Units

-1.1

Moneyline

2-1-0

Win %

66.67%

ROI

-9.02%

Units

-0.3

Over Rate

1-2-0

Win %

33.33%

ROI

-36.9%

Units

-1.1

Venue Splits

Thundering Herd Home

1-1-0 ATS

50% • -2.38%

0-2-0 ML (0%)

Dukes Home

0-1-0 ATS

0% • -100%

0-1-0 ML (0%)

Scoring Averages

Thundering Herd

19.3

PPG

22.3

allowed

Total

41.7

Avg

games

Dukes

22.3

PPG

19.3

allowed

Recent Matchups

Date	Matchup	Score	Spread	ATS	ML	O/U
11/082025-11-08	Dukes @ Thundering Herd	L 23-35	-13.5	✓	L	O
10/192023-10-19	Dukes @ Thundering Herd	L 9-20	-3.5	✗	L	U
10/222022-10-22	Thundering Herd @ Dukes	W 12-26	-9.5	✓	W	U

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Marshall Thundering Herd vs James Madison Dukes all-time record?

The Marshall Thundering Herd are 1-2 against the James Madison Dukes in head-to-head matchups.

What is the Marshall Thundering Herd ATS record vs the James Madison Dukes?

The Marshall Thundering Herd are 2-1-0 against the spread vs the James Madison Dukes on DraftKings, with +28.72% ROI.

Do Marshall Thundering Herd vs James Madison Dukes games go over or under?

Marshall Thundering Herd vs James Madison Dukes games average 41.7 total points. The Over has hit 33.33% of the time.

More Thundering Herd Matchups

See from Dukes perspective

Head-to-head betting record for Marshall Thundering Herd vs James Madison Dukes on LineTerminal. The Thundering Herd are 1-2 straight up against the Dukes and 2-1-0 against the spread (66.67% cover rate, +28.72% ROI) on DraftKings. Data sourced from DraftKings closing lines. Updated daily after games are graded. Past performance does not guarantee future results.