NHL Prop Leaderboards

Top 2025-26 NHL player prop performers ranked by over hit rate. Sort by ROI, games, or average actual. 484 players, 46,862 graded props.

Season

#	Player	Team
1	Jack Roslovic	Oilers	8-7	53.3%	+94.33%	0.6
2	Nikita Kucherov	Lightning	28-29	49.1%	+21.84%	0.6
3	Brandon Hagel	Lightning	27-28	49.1%	+46.82%	0.6
4	Cole Caufield	Canadiens	34-37	47.9%	+21.83%	0.7
5	Nathan MacKinnon	Avalanche	34-37	47.9%	-5.11%	0.7
6	Matt Boldy	Wild	30-34	46.9%	+22.89%	0.6
7	Kirill Kaprizov	Wild	30-35	46.2%	+0.48%	0.5
8	Zach Hyman	Oilers	24-28	46.2%	+23.27%	0.5
9	Wyatt Johnston	Stars	33-40	45.2%	+22.74%	0.5
10	Tage Thompson	Sabres	30-37	44.8%	+8.73%	0.5
11	Brad Marchand	Panthers	21-26	44.7%	+31.49%	0.5
12	Tyson Foerster	Flyers	7-9	43.8%	+62.5%	0.5
13	Jason Robertson	Stars	31-41	43.1%	+4.31%	0.5
14	Leon Draisaitl	Oilers	26-35	42.6%	-7.02%	0.5
15	Jared McCann	Kraken	17-23	42.5%	+44.13%	0.5
16	Connor McDavid	Oilers	30-41	42.3%	-1.55%	0.6
17	Alex DeBrincat	Wings	30-41	42.3%	+8.24%	0.5
18	William Nylander	Maple Leafs	22-30	42.3%	+16.92%	0.5
19	Macklin Celebrini	Sharks	29-40	42%	+10%	0.5
20	Auston Matthews	Maple Leafs	20-28	41.7%	-7.19%	0.5
21	Anthony Duclair	Islanders	5-7	41.7%	+69.17%	0.5
22	Cutter Gauthier	Ducks	26-37	41.3%	+18.25%	0.5
23	Martin Necas	Avalanche	28-40	41.2%	+12.57%	0.5
24	Filip Forsberg	Predators	29-43	40.3%	+10.28%	0.5
25	Dylan Guenther	Mammoth	27-40	40.3%	+14.25%	0.5
26	Kyle Connor	Jets	30-45	40%	-0.33%	0.5
27	Sam Reinhart	Panthers	23-35	39.7%	+3.79%	0.4
28	Sidney Crosby	Penguins	23-35	39.7%	+8.36%	0.5
29	Jake Guentzel	Lightning	24-37	39.3%	+3.93%	0.5
30	Seth Jarvis	Hurricanes	23-36	39%	+3.05%	0.5
31	Steven Stamkos	Predators	28-44	38.9%	+24.24%	0.5
32	Bo Horvat	Islanders	24-38	38.7%	+4.6%	0.5
33	Connor Bedard	Blackhawks	22-35	38.6%	+6.05%	0.4
34	Brock Nelson	Avalanche	22-35	38.6%	+27.28%	0.5
35	Dylan Larkin	Wings	25-40	38.5%	+4.85%	0.4
36	Tim Stützle	Senators	26-42	38.2%	+10.81%	0.4
37	Mark Stone	Golden Knights	18-30	37.5%	+11.98%	0.5
38	Anthony Cirelli	Lightning	10-17	37%	+40.74%	0.4
39	Alex Tuch	Sabres	24-41	36.9%	+18.08%	0.4
40	Matthew Tkachuk	Panthers	7-12	36.8%	+5.79%	0.5
41	Bryan Rust	Penguins	22-39	36.1%	+11.31%	0.4
42	Mark Scheifele	Jets	27-48	36%	-0.07%	0.5
43	Anthony Mantha	Penguins	14-25	35.9%	+40.51%	0.4
44	Mika Zibanejad	Rangers	24-44	35.3%	+2.87%	0.4
45	Tom Wilson	Capitals	21-39	35%	+6.67%	0.5
46	Leo Carlsson	Ducks	19-37	33.9%	+9.55%	0.4
47	Morgan Geekie	Bruins	24-47	33.8%	-1.48%	0.4
48	David Pastrnak	Bruins	23-45	33.8%	-20.96%	0.4
49	Drake Batherson	Senators	22-43	33.8%	+9.92%	0.5
50	Lucas Raymond	Wings	23-46	33.3%	+10.43%	0.4

50 players with 10+ games

Rankings based on historical closing lines from DraftKings, FanDuel, and BetMGM, graded against official NHL box scores. ROI calculated on flat $100 bets. Updated daily.