Who won Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders on Apr 9, 2026?

New York Islanders won 3-5 on Apr 9, 2026.

Maple Leafs 3, Islanders 5 — Apr 9, 2026 Recap

NHLTHU, APR 9, 20265:55 PM CDT

Away

Maple LeafsToronto Maple Leafs3

Final

Home

IslandersNew York Islanders5

Betting Results

Spread

Islanders covered

Islanders -1.5

Total

Over

8 / 6.5

Moneyline

Islanders

-298

Loading probability

Pre-Game Notes4 notes

NYI

Rest advantage

+4 days off

TOR

Back-to-back

No rest day

TOR

Lost 3 straight

Maple Leafs cold

NYI

Lost 4 straight

Islanders cold

Key Performers

Maple Leafs

Jake McCabeCold82g

0.3PTSL5 0.2

0.1G0.2A22mTOI

vs Islanders0PTS3g

Morgan RiellyCold80g

0.5PTSL5 0.2

0.1G0.3A21mTOI

vs Islanders0.3PTS3g

Auston MatthewsCold61g

0.9PTSL5 0.2

0.4G0.4A20mTOI

vs Islanders2PTS1g

Oliver Ekman-LarssonCold79g

0.5PTSL5 0.2

0.1G0.4A20mTOI

vs Islanders0.3PTS3g

Troy Stecher60g

0.2PTS

0.1G0.2A19mTOI

vs Islanders0PTS3g

Goalie

Joseph WollCold62g

.897SV%3.45GAA

L5 .825 SV% · 3.68 GAA

Islanders

Matthew SchaeferCold84g

0.7PTSL5 0.4

0.3G0.5A24mTOI

vs Maple Leafs1.3PTS3g

Adam Pelech84g

0.2PTS

0G0.1A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs0.7PTS3g

Ryan PulockCold78g

0.3PTSL5 0.2

0G0.3A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs0PTS3g

Bo HorvatCold70g

0.8PTSL5 0.4

0.5G0.4A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs0.5PTS2g

Mathew BarzalCold83g

0.9PTSL5 0.6

0.2G0.7A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs2PTS3g

Goalie

David Rittich84g

.894SV%2.78GAA

ScoringSeason · per game

Team

GPG

Scored

OPP

Allowed

MARGIN

Per game

Maple Leafs

3.1★

3.6★

-0.5★

Islanders

2.9★

0.0★

Edge

Maple Leafs +0.2

Islanders +0.7

Islanders +0.5

Last 10 · Trend

Maple Leafs

2.7avg

Islanders

2.6avg

Head-to-Head2025-26 · 2 games

Maple Leafs0

Islanders2

Jan 3

Maple Leafs3@4Islanders

Islanders +1 Mar 17

Islanders3@1Maple Leafs

Islanders +2

Recent FormLast 10

Straight-Up

Maple LeafsL3

3-730%

IslandersL4

3-730%

Against the Spread

Maple Leafs

5-550%

Islanders

6-460%

Season Records2025-26 · 78g / 78g

Team

ATS

O/U

Maple Leafs

Overall

41%32-46

42%33-45

56%44-34

Islanders

Overall

54%42-36

53%41-37

49%38-40

Matchup VenueRoad / Home splits

Team

ATS

O/U

Maple Leafs

On Road

36%14-25

46%18-21

54%21-18

Islanders

At Home

57%21-16

46%17-20

54%20-17

Player Prop Results23 players · 63 props

Anders LeeNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

2✗

Bo HorvatNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 3.5

2✗

Brayden SchennSt Louis Blues

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

3✓

Calum RitchieNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

PointsO 0.5

2✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

4✓

Easton CowanToronto Maple Leafs

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

1✗

Emil HeinemanNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

3✓

John TavaresToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 2.5

1✗

Mathew BarzalNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 1.5

1✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

4✓

Matias MaccelliToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Matthew KniesToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 1.5

0✗

Matthew SchaeferNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 2.5

3✓

Shots on GoalO 3.5

3✗

Max DomiToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Morgan RiellyToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

3✓

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

2✓

Oliver Ekman-LarssonToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Simon HolmstromNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 1.5

3✓

Tony DeAngeloNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

2✓

PointsO 0.5

2✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

4✓

William NylanderToronto Maple Leafs

5 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

2✗

Shots on GoalO 3.5

2✗

Jake McCabeToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 2.5

2✗

Ryan PulockNew York Islanders

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

2✓

Simon BenoitToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

0✗

Adam PelechNew York Islanders

1 prop

Shots on GoalO 1.5

4✓

Nicholas RobertsonToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Shots on GoalO 1.5

0✗

Ilya SorokinNew York Islanders

1 prop

SavesO 22.5

13✗

EV Picks

NHLTHU, APR 9, 20265:55 PM CDT

Away

Maple LeafsToronto Maple Leafs3

Final

Home

IslandersNew York Islanders5

Betting Results

Spread

Islanders covered

Islanders -1.5

Total

Over

8 / 6.5

Moneyline

Islanders

-298

Loading probability

Pre-Game Notes4 notes

NYI

Rest advantage

+4 days off

TOR

Back-to-back

No rest day

TOR

Lost 3 straight

Maple Leafs cold

NYI

Lost 4 straight

Islanders cold

Key Performers

Maple Leafs

Jake McCabeCold82g

0.3PTSL5 0.2

0.1G0.2A22mTOI

vs Islanders0PTS3g

Morgan RiellyCold80g

0.5PTSL5 0.2

0.1G0.3A21mTOI

vs Islanders0.3PTS3g

Auston MatthewsCold61g

0.9PTSL5 0.2

0.4G0.4A20mTOI

vs Islanders2PTS1g

Oliver Ekman-LarssonCold79g

0.5PTSL5 0.2

0.1G0.4A20mTOI

vs Islanders0.3PTS3g

Troy Stecher60g

0.2PTS

0.1G0.2A19mTOI

vs Islanders0PTS3g

Goalie

Joseph WollCold62g

.897SV%3.45GAA

L5 .825 SV% · 3.68 GAA

Islanders

Matthew SchaeferCold84g

0.7PTSL5 0.4

0.3G0.5A24mTOI

vs Maple Leafs1.3PTS3g

Adam Pelech84g

0.2PTS

0G0.1A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs0.7PTS3g

Ryan PulockCold78g

0.3PTSL5 0.2

0G0.3A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs0PTS3g

Bo HorvatCold70g

0.8PTSL5 0.4

0.5G0.4A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs0.5PTS2g

Mathew BarzalCold83g

0.9PTSL5 0.6

0.2G0.7A20mTOI

vs Maple Leafs2PTS3g

Goalie

David Rittich84g

.894SV%2.78GAA

ScoringSeason · per game

Team

GPG

Scored

OPP

Allowed

MARGIN

Per game

Maple Leafs

3.1★

3.6★

-0.5★

Islanders

2.9★

0.0★

Edge

Maple Leafs +0.2

Islanders +0.7

Islanders +0.5

Last 10 · Trend

Maple Leafs

2.7avg

Islanders

2.6avg

Head-to-Head2025-26 · 2 games

Maple Leafs0

Islanders2

Jan 3

Maple Leafs3@4Islanders

Islanders +1 Mar 17

Islanders3@1Maple Leafs

Islanders +2

Recent FormLast 10

Straight-Up

Maple LeafsL3

3-730%

IslandersL4

3-730%

Against the Spread

Maple Leafs

5-550%

Islanders

6-460%

Season Records2025-26 · 78g / 78g

Team

ATS

O/U

Maple Leafs

Overall

41%32-46

42%33-45

56%44-34

Islanders

Overall

54%42-36

53%41-37

49%38-40

Matchup VenueRoad / Home splits

Team

ATS

O/U

Maple Leafs

On Road

36%14-25

46%18-21

54%21-18

Islanders

At Home

57%21-16

46%17-20

54%20-17

Player Prop Results23 players · 63 props

Anders LeeNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

2✗

Bo HorvatNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 3.5

2✗

Brayden SchennSt Louis Blues

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

3✓

Calum RitchieNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

PointsO 0.5

2✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

4✓

Easton CowanToronto Maple Leafs

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

1✗

Emil HeinemanNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

3✓

John TavaresToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 2.5

1✗

Mathew BarzalNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 1.5

1✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

4✓

Matias MaccelliToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Matthew KniesToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 1.5

0✗

Matthew SchaeferNew York Islanders

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 2.5

3✓

Shots on GoalO 3.5

3✗

Max DomiToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Morgan RiellyToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

3✓

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

2✓

Oliver Ekman-LarssonToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

PointsO 0.5

1✓

Simon HolmstromNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 1.5

3✓

Tony DeAngeloNew York Islanders

3 props

AssistsO 0.5

2✓

PointsO 0.5

2✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

4✓

William NylanderToronto Maple Leafs

5 props

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

PointsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

2✗

Shots on GoalO 3.5

2✗

Jake McCabeToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 2.5

2✗

Ryan PulockNew York Islanders

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

2✓

Simon BenoitToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

0✗

Adam PelechNew York Islanders

1 prop

Shots on GoalO 1.5

4✓

Nicholas RobertsonToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Shots on GoalO 1.5

0✗

Ilya SorokinNew York Islanders

1 prop

SavesO 22.5

13✗