Who won Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders on Jan 3, 2026?

New York Islanders won 3-4 on Jan 3, 2026.

Maple Leafs 3, Islanders 4 — Jan 3, 2026 Recap

NHLSAT, JAN 3, 20266:10 PM CDT

Away

Maple LeafsToronto Maple Leafs3

Final

Home

IslandersNew York Islanders4

Betting results

Spread

Islanders covered

Islanders +1.5

Total

Over

7 / 5.5

Moneyline

Islanders

-105

Probability

Loading probability

Pre-game notes3 notes

4 games / 7dMaple Leafs in a stretch

Lost ATS 3 straightIslanders hasn't covered in 3

4 games / 7dIslanders in a stretch

Key performers

Maple Leafs

Jake McCabe82g0.3PTS

0.1G0.2A22mTOI

Last 5: 0.2 pts·vs Islanders: 0 pts (3g)

Morgan Rielly80g0.5PTS

0.1G0.3A21mTOI

Last 5: 0.2 pts·vs Islanders: 0.3 pts (3g)

Auston Matthews61g0.9PTS

0.4G0.4A20mTOI

Last 5: 0.2 pts·vs Islanders: 2 pts (1g)

Oliver Ekman-Larsson79g0.5PTS

0.1G0.4A20mTOI

Last 5: 0.2 pts·vs Islanders: 0.3 pts (3g)

Troy Stecher60g0.2PTS

0.1G0.2A19mTOI

Last 5: 0.2 pts·vs Islanders: 0 pts (3g)

Goalie

Joseph WollCold62g

.897SV%3.45GAA

L5 .825 SV% · 3.68 GAA

Islanders

Matthew Schaefer84g0.7PTS

0.3G0.5A24mTOI

Last 5: 0.4 pts·vs Maple Leafs: 1.3 pts (3g)

Adam Pelech84g0.2PTS

0G0.1A20mTOI

Last 5: 0.2 pts·vs Maple Leafs: 0.7 pts (3g)

Ryan Pulock78g0.3PTS

0G0.3A20mTOI

Last 5: 0.2 pts·vs Maple Leafs: 0 pts (3g)

Bo Horvat70g0.8PTS

0.5G0.4A20mTOI

Last 5: 0.4 pts·vs Maple Leafs: 0.5 pts (2g)

Mathew Barzal83g0.9PTS

0.2G0.7A20mTOI

Last 5: 0.6 pts·vs Maple Leafs: 2 pts (3g)

Goalie

David Rittich84g

.894SV%2.78GAA

ScoringSeason · per game

Team

GPG

Scored

OPP

Allowed

MARGIN

Per game

Maple Leafs

3.4★

0.0★

Islanders

2.8★

2.9★

0.0★

Edge

Maple Leafs +0.6

Islanders +0.5

even

Last 10 · Trend

Maple Leafs

3.5avg

Islanders

2.4avg

Recent formLast 10

Straight-Up

Maple Leafs

5-550%

Islanders

5-550%

Against the Spread

Maple Leafs

4-640%

Islanders3 fail

6-460%

Season records2025-26 · 40g / 41g

Team

ATS

O/U

Maple Leafs

Overall

48%19-21

40%16-24

57%23-17

Islanders

Overall

54%22-19

51%21-20

44%18-23

Matchup venueRoad / Home splits

Team

ATS

O/U

Maple Leafs

On Road

31%5-11

38%6-10

50%8-8

Islanders

At Home

55%12-10

41%9-13

50%11-11

Player prop results21 players · 56 props

Bobby McMannToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

PointsO 0.5

1✓

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

0✗

Auston MatthewsToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

PointsO 0.5

2✓

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

2✓

Shots on GoalO 3.5

6✓

Mathew BarzalNew York Islanders

4 props

PointsO 0.5

2✓

AssistsO 0.5

2✓

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

2✗

Emil HeinemanNew York Islanders

4 props

PointsO 0.5

2✓

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

GoalsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 2.5

2✗

John TavaresToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

PointsO 0.5

0✗

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

1✗

Anders LeeNew York Islanders

4 props

PointsO 0.5

0✗

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

1✗

Matthew KniesToronto Maple Leafs

4 props

PointsO 0.5

0✗

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

GoalsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 1.5

0✗

Morgan RiellyToronto Maple Leafs

3 props

PointsO 0.5

0✗

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 1.5

1✗

Tony DeAngeloNew York Islanders

3 props

PointsO 0.5

1✓

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

2✓

Matthew SchaeferNew York Islanders

3 props

PointsO 0.5

2✓

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

Shots on GoalO 2.5

2✗

Jonathan DrouinNew York Islanders

3 props

PointsO 0.5

2✓

AssistsO 0.5

2✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

1✗

Max DomiToronto Maple Leafs

3 props

PointsO 0.5

1✓

AssistsO 0.5

1✓

Shots on GoalO 1.5

0✗

Matias MaccelliToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

PointsO 0.5

0✗

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

Oliver Ekman-LarssonToronto Maple Leafs

2 props

PointsO 0.5

0✗

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

Simon HolmstromNew York Islanders

2 props

PointsO 0.5

0✗

AssistsO 0.5

0✗

Jake McCabeToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 2.5

1✗

Ryan PulockNew York Islanders

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

1✗

Joseph WollToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

SavesO 25.5

21✗

David RittichNew York Islanders

1 prop

SavesO 23.5

18✗

Simon BenoitToronto Maple Leafs

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

1✗

Adam PelechNew York Islanders

1 prop

Blocked ShotsO 1.5

1✗

EV picks