Penguins 3, Maple Leafs 6 — Dec 23, 2025 Recap

Toronto Maple Leafs beat Pittsburgh Penguins 3-6 on Dec 23, 2025.

Game FAQ — score, spread, and total

Who won Pittsburgh Penguins vs Toronto Maple Leafs on Dec 23, 2025?

Toronto Maple Leafs won 3-6 on Dec 23, 2025.

See methodology for grading rules and ROI calculation.

NHLTUE, DEC 23, 20253:00 PM CT
Spread
Maple Leafs covered
Maple Leafs -1.5
Total
Over
9 / 6.5
Moneyline
Maple Leafs
-134
Loading probability
PIT
Lost ATS 4 straight
Penguins hasn't covered in 4
PIT
4 games / 7d
Penguins in a stretch
TOR
Lost 3 straight
Maple Leafs cold
TOR
Lost ATS 6 straight
Maple Leafs hasn't covered in 6
TOR
4 games / 7d
Maple Leafs in a stretch
Penguins
Erik Karlsson
0.9PTSL5 0.4
0.2G0.7A23mTOI
vs Maple Leafs0.3PTS3g
Kris Letang
0.4PTS
0.1G0.4A21mTOI
vs Maple Leafs0.3PTS3g
Brett Kulak
0.3PTSL5 0.4
0G0.2A20mTOI
vs Maple Leafs0PTS1g
Parker Wotherspoon
0.4PTSL5 0.2
0G0.3A20mTOI
vs Maple Leafs0.3PTS3g
Bryan Rust
Bryan RustCold80g
0.8PTSL5 0.2
0.4G0.5A20mTOI
vs Maple Leafs1PTS3g
Goalie
Arturs Silovs
.891SV%2.97GAA
L5 .949 SV% · 1.24 GAA
Maple Leafs
Jake McCabe
0.3PTSL5 0.2
0.1G0.2A22mTOI
vs Penguins0.3PTS3g
Morgan Rielly
0.5PTSL5 0.2
0.1G0.3A21mTOI
vs Penguins1.3PTS3g
Auston Matthews
0.9PTSL5 0.2
0.4G0.4A20mTOI
vs Penguins1.3PTS3g
Oliver Ekman-Larsson
0.5PTSL5 0.2
0.1G0.4A20mTOI
vs Penguins1.3PTS3g
Troy Stecher
0.2PTS
0.1G0.2A19mTOI
vs Penguins0.5PTS2g
Goalie
Joseph Woll
.897SV%3.45GAA
L5 .825 SV% · 3.68 GAA
GPG
Scored
OPP
Allowed
MARGIN
Per game
Penguins
3.1
3.2
-0.2
Maple Leafs
3.1
3.4
-0.3
Edge
even
Penguins +0.2
Penguins +0.1
Last 10 · Trend
Penguins
2.8avg
Maple Leafs
2.4avg
Straight-Up
Penguins
2-820%
W
L
L
L
L
L
L
L
L
W
Maple LeafsL3
4-640%
W
W
L
W
L
L
W
L
L
L
Against the Spread
Penguins4 fail
3-730%
W
W
L
L
L
W
L
L
L
L
Maple Leafs6 fail
3-730%
W
W
L
W
L
L
L
L
L
L
Team
SU
ATS
O/U
Penguins
Overall
43%15-20
60%21-14
51%18-17
Maple Leafs
Overall
43%15-20
34%12-23
57%20-15
Team
SU
ATS
O/U
Penguins
On Road
47%8-9
76%13-4
41%7-10
Maple Leafs
At Home
50%10-10
35%7-13
60%12-8
Anthony Mantha
Anthony ManthaPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
GoalsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 1.5
3
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
1
William Nylander
William NylanderToronto Maple Leafs
4 props
GoalsO 0.5
2
Shots on GoalO 2.5
3
AssistsO 0.5
2
PointsO 0.5
4
Rickard Rakell
Rickard RakellPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
GoalsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 2.5
3
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
John Tavares
John TavaresToronto Maple Leafs
4 props
GoalsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 2.5
2
AssistsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
1
Auston Matthews
Auston MatthewsToronto Maple Leafs
4 props
GoalsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 3.5
3
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Bryan Rust
Bryan RustPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
GoalsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 2.5
3
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
1
Sidney Crosby
Sidney CrosbyPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
GoalsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 2.5
2
AssistsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
1
Ben Kindel
Ben KindelPittsburgh Penguins
3 props
Shots on GoalO 1.5
1
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Morgan Rielly
Morgan RiellyToronto Maple Leafs
4 props
Shots on GoalO 1.5
1
AssistsO 0.5
0
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
1
PointsO 0.5
0
Erik Karlsson
Erik KarlssonPittsburgh Penguins
3 props
Shots on GoalO 2.5
6
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Matthew Knies
Matthew KniesToronto Maple Leafs
3 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 1.5
0
PointsO 0.5
1
Oliver Ekman-Larsson
Oliver Ekman-LarssonToronto Maple Leafs
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
1
Kris Letang
Kris LetangPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 1.5
2
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
2
PointsO 0.5
1
Max Domi
Max DomiToronto Maple Leafs
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
2
Matias Maccelli
Matias MaccelliToronto Maple Leafs
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
1
Bobby McMann
Bobby McMannToronto Maple Leafs
3 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 1.5
4
PointsO 0.5
1
Nicholas Robertson
Nicholas RobertsonToronto Maple Leafs
3 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 1.5
1
PointsO 0.5
0
Nicolas Roy
Nicolas RoyToronto Maple Leafs
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Tommy Novak
Tommy NovakPittsburgh Penguins
3 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 1.5
2
PointsO 0.5
0
Justin Brazeau
Justin BrazeauPittsburgh Penguins
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
1
Jake McCabe
Jake McCabeToronto Maple Leafs
1 prop
Blocked ShotsO 2.5
2
Parker Wotherspoon
Parker WotherspoonPittsburgh Penguins
1 prop
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
2
Brett Kulak
Brett KulakPittsburgh Penguins
1 prop
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
1
Joseph Woll
Joseph WollToronto Maple Leafs
1 prop
SavesO 25.5
29
Stuart Skinner
Stuart SkinnerPittsburgh Penguins
1 prop
SavesO 23.5
25
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
P