Islanders 3, Penguins 4 — Oct 9, 2025 Recap

Pittsburgh Penguins beat New York Islanders 3-4 on Oct 9, 2025.

Game FAQ — score, spread, and total

Who won New York Islanders vs Pittsburgh Penguins on Oct 9, 2025?

Pittsburgh Penguins won 3-4 on Oct 9, 2025.

See methodology for grading rules and ROI calculation.

NHLTHU, OCT 9, 20256:10 PM CT
Spread
Penguins covered
Penguins +1.5
Total
Over
7 / 6
Moneyline
Penguins
+109
Loading probability
Islanders
Matthew Schaefer
0.7PTSL5 0.4
0.3G0.5A24mTOI
vs Penguins1PTS3g
Adam Pelech
0.2PTS
0G0.1A20mTOI
vs Penguins0.3PTS3g
Ryan Pulock
0.3PTSL5 0.2
0G0.3A20mTOI
vs Penguins0.3PTS3g
Bo Horvat
Bo HorvatCold70g
0.8PTSL5 0.4
0.5G0.4A20mTOI
vs Penguins1PTS3g
Mathew Barzal
0.9PTSL5 0.6
0.2G0.7A20mTOI
vs Penguins2PTS3g
Goalie
David Rittich
.894SV%2.78GAA
Penguins
Erik Karlsson
0.9PTSL5 0.4
0.2G0.7A23mTOI
vs Islanders0.3PTS3g
Kris Letang
0.4PTS
0.1G0.4A21mTOI
vs Islanders1PTS2g
Brett Kulak
0.3PTSL5 0.4
0G0.2A20mTOI
vs Islanders1PTS1g
Parker Wotherspoon
0.4PTSL5 0.2
0G0.3A20mTOI
vs Islanders0.7PTS3g
Bryan Rust
Bryan RustCold80g
0.8PTSL5 0.2
0.4G0.5A20mTOI
vs Islanders1.5PTS2g
Goalie
Arturs Silovs
.891SV%2.97GAA
L5 .949 SV% · 1.24 GAA
Straight-Up
Penguins
1-0100%
W
Against the Spread
Penguins
1-0100%
W
Team
SU
ATS
O/U
Islanders
Overall
0%0-0
0%0-0
0%0-0
Penguins
Overall
100%1-0
100%1-0
0%0-1
Sidney Crosby
Sidney CrosbyPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 2.5
1
GoalsO 0.5
1
PointsO 1.5
2
Mathew Barzal
Mathew BarzalNew York Islanders
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 2.5
4
GoalsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
1
Rickard Rakell
Rickard RakellPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 2.5
2
GoalsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
2
Erik Karlsson
Erik KarlssonPittsburgh Penguins
3 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 2.5
2
PointsO 0.5
0
Bo Horvat
Bo HorvatNew York Islanders
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 2.5
7
GoalsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Evgeni Malkin
Evgeni MalkinPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
3
Shots on GoalO 1.5
4
GoalsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
3
Tony DeAngelo
Tony DeAngeloNew York Islanders
3 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 1.5
3
PointsO 0.5
0
Kris Letang
Kris LetangPittsburgh Penguins
5 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 1.5
4
Shots on GoalO 2.5
4
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Ville Koivunen
Ville KoivunenPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 1.5
1
GoalsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Anders Lee
Anders LeeNew York Islanders
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 2.5
4
GoalsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Kyle Palmieri
Kyle PalmieriNew York Islanders
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
Shots on GoalO 1.5
8
GoalsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
1
Anthony Mantha
Anthony ManthaPittsburgh Penguins
4 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
Shots on GoalO 1.5
1
GoalsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
1
Jean-Gabriel Pageau
Jean-Gabriel PageauNew York Islanders
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
0
PointsO 0.5
0
Simon Holmstrom
Simon HolmstromNew York Islanders
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
1
Matthew Schaefer
Matthew SchaeferNew York Islanders
2 props
AssistsO 0.5
1
PointsO 0.5
1
Alexander Romanov
Alexander RomanovNew York Islanders
1 prop
Blocked ShotsO 2.5
2
Ryan Pulock
Ryan PulockNew York Islanders
1 prop
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
1
Scott Mayfield
Scott MayfieldNew York Islanders
1 prop
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
0
Parker Wotherspoon
Parker WotherspoonPittsburgh Penguins
1 prop
Blocked ShotsO 1.5
1
Tristan Jarry
Tristan JarryPittsburgh Penguins
1 prop
SavesO 25.5
34
Ilya Sorokin
Ilya SorokinNew York Islanders
1 prop
SavesO 24.5
24