LineTerminalLineTerminal
NFLSoon
NCAAFSoon
HomePropsScheduleLineupsInside EdgeTeamsPlayers

Guardians 4, Reds 5 — May 16, 2025 Recap

Cincinnati Reds beat Cleveland Guardians 4-5 on May 16, 2025.

Game FAQ — score, spread, and total

Who won Cleveland Guardians vs Cincinnati Reds on May 16, 2025?

Cincinnati Reds won 4-5 on May 16, 2025.

See methodology for grading rules and ROI calculation.

MLBFRI, MAY 16, 20255:40 PM CT
AwayGuardians4
Final
HomeReds5

Betting Results

Spread
Guardians covered
Reds -2.5
Total
Under
9 / 12.5
Moneyline
Reds
-500
Loading probability

Starting PitchersConfirmed

Guardians
Tanner Bibee
Tanner Bibee
4.06 ERA3-451.0 IP35 K1.29 WHIP
Reds
Brady Singer
Brady Singer
5.01 ERA5-246.2 IP43 K1.31 WHIP

Linescore

123456789RHE
Guardians
000210010450
Reds
0410000005110

Box Score — Hitting

Guardians
BatterPOSABRHRBIHRBBK
Nolan JonesCF4000002
Daniel Schneemann2B3010011
José Ramírez3B4111100
Gabriel AriasSS2000011
Bo NaylorC3111101
Will BrennanRF3000000
Steven KwanLF3100010
Kyle ManzardoDH4110000
Carlos Santana1B4012000
Totals30454235
Reds
BatterPOSABRHRBIHRBBK
Austin HaysLF4121100
Will BensonRF4123100
Spencer Steer1B4110000
Santiago Espinal3B4010000
Tyler StephensonC4010002
TJ FriedlCF3000011
Elly De La CruzSS3010011
Gavin LuxDH4120001
Matt McLain2B4110002
Totals345114227

Box Score — Pitching

Guardians
PitcherIPHRERBBKHRPC
Tanner BibeeL6.01054142105
Matt Festa2.010013028
Reds
PitcherIPHRERBBKHRPC
Brady SingerW5.033334190
Graham AshcraftH1.01000005
Emilio PagánS1.000001016
Taylor RogersH1.000000012
Tony SantillanH1.011100111

Season Records2026 · 0g / 0g

Team
SU
ATS
O/U
Guardians
Overall
0%0-0
0%0-0
0%0-0
Reds
Overall
0%0-0
0%0-0
0%0-0

Player Prop Results18 players · 104 props

Jose Ramirez
Jose RamirezCleveland Guardians
9 props
HitsO 0.5
1✓
Home RunsO 0.5
1✓
RBIsO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1✗
Total BasesO 1.5
4✓
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
3✓
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
Tyler Stephenson
Tyler StephensonCincinnati Reds
7 props
HitsO 0.5
1✓
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
Total BasesO 1.5
1✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
1✓
SinglesO 0.5
1✓
Gabriel Arias
Gabriel AriasCleveland Guardians
7 props
HitsO 0.5
0✗
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0✗
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
Daniel Schneemann
Daniel SchneemannCleveland Guardians
6 props
HitsO 0.5
1✓
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
1✓
SinglesO 0.5
1✓
Will Brennan
Will BrennanCleveland Guardians
6 props
HitsO 0.5
0✗
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0✗
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
Steven Kwan
Steven KwanCleveland Guardians
6 props
HitsO 0.5
0✗
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
1✗
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
TJ Friedl
TJ FriedlCincinnati Reds
6 props
HitsO 0.5
0✗
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0✗
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
Nolan Jones
Nolan JonesCleveland Guardians
6 props
HitsO 0.5
0✗
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0✗
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
Kyle Manzardo
Kyle ManzardoCleveland Guardians
7 props
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1✗
DoublesO 1.5
1✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
2✗
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
Spencer Steer
Spencer SteerCincinnati Reds
4 props
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1✗
Carlos Santana
Carlos SantanaCleveland Guardians
5 props
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
Total BasesO 1.5
1✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
3✗
SinglesO 1.5
1✗
Matt McLain
Matt McLainCincinnati Reds
8 props
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1✗
Total BasesO 1.5
1✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
2✗
SinglesO 1.5
1✗
Gavin Lux
Gavin LuxCincinnati Reds
4 props
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1✗
Santiago Espinal
Santiago EspinalCincinnati Reds
6 props
Home RunsO 0.5
0✗
RBIsO 1.5
0✗
Total BasesO 1.5
1✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
1✗
SinglesO 1.5
1✗
Austin Hays
Austin HaysCincinnati Reds
3 props
RBIsO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1✗
Bo Naylor
Bo NaylorCleveland Guardians
4 props
RBIsO 1.5
1✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
3✗
SinglesO 0.5
0✗
Will Benson
Will BensonCincinnati Reds
5 props
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1✗
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1✗
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 5.5
6✓
SinglesO 0.5
1✓
Elly De La Cruz
Elly De La CruzCincinnati Reds
5 props
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0✗
Stolen BasesO 0.5
1✓
DoublesO 0.5
0✗
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
1✗
SinglesO 1.5
1✗

EV Picks