Mets 4, Cardinals 5 — May 4, 2025 Recap

St. Louis Cardinals beat New York Mets 4-5 on May 4, 2025.

Game FAQ — score, spread, and total

Who won New York Mets vs St. Louis Cardinals on May 4, 2025?

St. Louis Cardinals won 4-5 on May 4, 2025.

See methodology for grading rules and ROI calculation.

MLBSUN, MAY 4, 20255:15 PM CT
Spread
Cardinals covered
Cardinals +1.5
Total
Over
9 / 7.5
Moneyline
Cardinals
+136
Loading probability
NYM
Lost ATS 4 straight
Mets hasn't covered in 4
Mets
Blade Tidwell
14.73 ERA0-13.2 IP2 K3.27 WHIP
Cardinals
Erick Fedde
4.78 ERA2-337.2 IP21 K1.46 WHIP
123456789RHE
Mets
1010010205200
Cardinals
0114000006200
Mets
BatterPOSABRHRBIHRBBK
Pete Alonso1B5120001
Jesse WinkerLF0001010
Juan SotoDH5110000
Brandon NimmoLF5000001
Juan SotoRF4110012
Brandon NimmoDH4011010
Mark Vientos3B2010010
Luis TorrensC3000021
Luisangel Acuña2B4130010
José AzocarCF3000001
Tyrone TaylorCF1010000
Francisco LindorSS4010011
José AzocarRF1000000
Luisangel Acuña2B4000002
Mark Vientos3B4120011
Starling MarteRF3022000
Francisco AlvarezC2011020
Tyrone TaylorCF3120000
Francisco LindorSS5013002
Jeff McNeilLF4200010
Pete Alonso1B4111011
Totals70920901313
Cardinals
BatterPOSABRHRBIHRBBK
Nolan Gorman2B2001011
Pedro PagésC4000001
Masyn WinnSS1100010
Brendan Donovan2B3010000
Nolan Arenado3B4121001
Yohel PozoC4120000
Victor Scott IICF3011012
Lars NootbaarRF5000001
Alec BurlesonDH4110010
Willson Contreras1B4133101
José Barrero2B3110001
Lars NootbaarLF4110010
Jordan WalkerRF4000002
Nolan Arenado3B4020010
Willson ContrerasDH4011002
Brendan DonovanLF4222010
Victor Scott IICF3120010
José BarreroSS3000001
Alec Burleson1B4112101
Totals671120112814
Mets
PitcherIPHRERBBKHRPC
Blade TidwellL3.296632182
Tylor Megill5.044436190
Génesis Cabrera2.020000023
Huascar Brazobán0.10000108
Max KranickL1.021101021
Ryne Stanek1.010001016
Edwin Díaz1.020001014
Austin Warren1.000011019
Reed Garrett1.000011021
Cardinals
PitcherIPHRERBBKHRPC
Erick FeddeW5.0633540101
Andre Pallante3.194441072
Phil MatonH0.132210021
JoJo RomeroH0.200011018
Michael McGreevyW5.210015080
Ryan HelsleyS1.010001014
Kyle LeahyH2.000011025
RPG
Scored
OPP
Allowed
MARGIN
Per game
Mets
4.0
4.3
-0.3
Cardinals
4.5
4.6
-0.1
Edge
Cardinals +0.5
Mets +0.3
Cardinals +0.2
Last 10 · Trend
Mets
5.6avg
Cardinals
3.5avg
Straight-Up
Mets
6-460%
W
W
L
W
W
W
L
L
W
L
Cardinals
5-550%
L
W
L
W
W
W
L
W
L
L
Against the Spread
Mets4 fail
5-550%
W
W
L
W
W
W
L
L
L
L
Cardinals
5-550%
W
W
L
L
W
W
L
W
L
L
Team
SU
ATS
O/U
Mets
Overall
43%22-29
39%20-31
44%21-27
Cardinals
Overall
57%28-21
59%29-20
47%22-25
Team
SU
ATS
O/U
Mets
On Road
41%11-16
41%11-16
33%9-18
Cardinals
At Home
50%13-13
58%15-11
52%13-12
Francisco Lindor
Francisco LindorNew York Mets
26 props
HitsO 1.5
1
HitsO 3.5
1
HitsO 0.5
1
HitsO 2.5
1
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Runs ScoredO 2.5
0
Stolen BasesO 1.5
1
Stolen BasesO 0.5
1
Total BasesO 2.5
1
Total BasesO 4.5
1
Total BasesO 1.5
1
Total BasesO 3.5
1
WalksO 0.5
1
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
4
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
4
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
4
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
4
SinglesO 0.5
1
Pete Alonso
Pete AlonsoNew York Mets
25 props
HitsO 1.5
2
HitsO 3.5
2
HitsO 0.5
2
HitsO 2.5
2
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
1
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1
Total BasesO 2.5
4
Total BasesO 4.5
4
Total BasesO 1.5
4
Total BasesO 3.5
4
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
3
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
3
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
3
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
3
SinglesO 0.5
1
Brendan Donovan
Brendan DonovanSt. Louis Cardinals
23 props
HitsO 1.5
1
HitsO 3.5
1
HitsO 0.5
1
HitsO 2.5
1
Home RunsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
1
Total BasesO 4.5
1
Total BasesO 1.5
1
Total BasesO 3.5
1
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
6
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
6
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
6
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
6
SinglesO 0.5
1
Alec Burleson
Alec BurlesonSt. Louis Cardinals
24 props
HitsO 1.5
1
HitsO 3.5
1
HitsO 0.5
1
HitsO 2.5
1
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
1
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
1
Total BasesO 4.5
1
Total BasesO 1.5
1
Total BasesO 3.5
1
WalksO 0.5
1
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
2
SinglesO 0.5
0
Juan Soto
Juan SotoNew York Mets
25 props
HitsO 1.5
1
HitsO 3.5
1
HitsO 0.5
1
HitsO 2.5
1
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
1
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1
Runs ScoredO 2.5
1
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
1
Total BasesO 4.5
1
Total BasesO 1.5
1
Total BasesO 3.5
1
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
2
SinglesO 0.5
1
Brandon Nimmo
Brandon NimmoNew York Mets
24 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 3.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
1
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
2
SinglesO 0.5
0
Lars Nootbaar
Lars NootbaarSt. Louis Cardinals
25 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Runs ScoredO 2.5
0
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
0
SinglesO 0.5
0
Luisangel Acuña
Luisangel AcuñaNew York Mets
23 props
HitsO 1.5
3
HitsO 0.5
3
HitsO 2.5
3
Home RunsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
1
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1
Stolen BasesO 1.5
1
Stolen BasesO 0.5
1
Total BasesO 2.5
3
Total BasesO 4.5
3
Total BasesO 1.5
3
Total BasesO 3.5
3
Total BasesO 0.5
3
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
4
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
4
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
4
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
4
SinglesO 0.5
0
Luis Torrens
Luis TorrensNew York Mets
23 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
2
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
0
SinglesO 0.5
0
Jeff McNeil
Jeff McNeilNew York Mets
23 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
2
Runs ScoredO 1.5
2
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
1
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
2
SinglesO 0.5
0
Nolan Arenado
Nolan ArenadoSt. Louis Cardinals
24 props
HitsO 1.5
2
HitsO 0.5
2
HitsO 2.5
2
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
1
RBIsO 2.5
1
RBIsO 0.5
1
RBIsO 3.5
1
Runs ScoredO 0.5
1
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
2
Total BasesO 4.5
2
Total BasesO 1.5
2
Total BasesO 3.5
2
Total BasesO 0.5
2
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
2
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
2
SinglesO 0.5
2
Willson Contreras
Willson ContrerasSt. Louis Cardinals
24 props
HitsO 1.5
3
HitsO 0.5
3
HitsO 2.5
3
Home RunsO 0.5
1
Home RunsO 1.5
1
RBIsO 1.5
3
RBIsO 2.5
3
RBIsO 0.5
3
RBIsO 3.5
3
Runs ScoredO 0.5
1
Runs ScoredO 1.5
1
Total BasesO 2.5
6
Total BasesO 4.5
6
Total BasesO 1.5
6
Total BasesO 3.5
6
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
6
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
7
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
7
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
7
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
7
SinglesO 0.5
1
Jose Azocar
Jose AzocarNew York Mets
22 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Stolen BasesO 1.5
0
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
0
SinglesO 0.5
0
Pedro Pages
Pedro PagesSt. Louis Cardinals
24 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 2.5
0
RBIsO 0.5
0
RBIsO 3.5
0
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
0
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
0
SinglesO 0.5
0
Victor Scott II
Victor Scott IISt. Louis Cardinals
25 props
HitsO 1.5
1
HitsO 0.5
1
HitsO 2.5
1
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
1
RBIsO 2.5
1
RBIsO 0.5
1
RBIsO 3.5
1
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Stolen BasesO 1.5
0
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
2
Total BasesO 4.5
2
Total BasesO 1.5
2
Total BasesO 3.5
2
Total BasesO 0.5
2
WalksO 0.5
1
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
3
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
3
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
3
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
3
SinglesO 0.5
2
Jesse Winker
Jesse WinkerNew York Mets
24 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
1
RBIsO 2.5
1
RBIsO 0.5
1
RBIsO 3.5
1
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
1
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
1
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
1
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
1
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
1
SinglesO 0.5
0
Nolan Gorman
Nolan GormanSt. Louis Cardinals
24 props
HitsO 1.5
0
HitsO 0.5
0
HitsO 2.5
0
Home RunsO 0.5
0
Home RunsO 1.5
0
RBIsO 1.5
1
RBIsO 2.5
1
RBIsO 0.5
1
RBIsO 3.5
1
Runs ScoredO 0.5
0
Runs ScoredO 1.5
0
Stolen BasesO 0.5
0
Total BasesO 2.5
0
Total BasesO 4.5
0
Total BasesO 1.5
0
Total BasesO 3.5
0
Total BasesO 0.5
0
WalksO 0.5
1
DoublesO 0.5
0
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 3.5
1
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 1.5
1
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 0.5
1
Hits+Runs+RBIsO 2.5
1
SinglesO 0.5
0
Erick Fedde
Erick FeddeSt. Louis Cardinals
4 props
Pitcher KsO 3.5
4
Earned RunsO 2.5
3
Hits AllowedO 5.5
6
Walks AllowedO 2.5
5
Blade Tidwell
Blade TidwellNew York Mets
4 props
Pitcher KsO 4.5
2
Earned RunsO 2.5
6
Hits AllowedO 4.5
9
Walks AllowedO 2.5
3