Jose Caballero

New York YankeesPosition Player•2026

Reg0.286 / 4 HR / 12 RBI / 32 H / 10 SB / 33G

64.1% HRR O 0.557.5% H O 0.556.4% SO O 0.5

Season

Best Performer

Jose Caballero goes over 0.5 hits+runs+rbis 64.1% of the time (25-14-4)

Props — 202644 games with closing lines

Hits

44g

avg 0.9

57.5%Over: 23-17-4

2vs O 0.5-140

Rays5/22

✓PP✓✗✓✗✗✓✓

H: 47.6%(21)A: 56.5%(23)

RBIs

44g

avg 0.3

20%Over: 8-32-4

0vs O 0.5+286

Rays5/22

✗PP✗✗✗✗✗✗✓

H: 19%(21)A: 17.4%(23)

Home Runs

44g

avg 0.1

10%Over: 4-36-4

0vs O 0.5+1140

Rays5/22

✗PP✗✗✗✗✗✗✗

H: 9.5%(21)A: 8.7%(23)

Runs Scored

44g

avg 0.5

37.5%Over: 15-25-4

0vs O 0.5+220

Rays5/22

✗PP✓✗✗✗✗✓✓

H: 47.6%(21)A: 21.7%(23)

Total Bases

44g

avg 1.5

37.5%Over: 15-25-4

2vs O 1.5+231

Rays5/22

✓PP✓✗✓✗✗✗✓

H: 38.1%(21)A: 30.4%(23)

Stolen Bases

43g

avg 0.3

27.5%Over: 11-29-3

0vs O 0.5+310

Rays5/22

✗P✗✗✗✗✗✗✗✓

H: 33.3%(21)A: 18.2%(22)

Strikeouts

43g

avg 0.5

56.4%Over: 22-17-4

0vs O 0.5-210

Orioles5/12

PP✗✓✓✗✗✗✗✗

H: 40%(20)A: 60.9%(23)

Doubles

43g

avg 0.2

15.4%Over: 6-33-4

0vs O 0.5+600

Rays5/22

✗PP✓✗✗✗✗✗✓

H: 15%(20)A: 13%(23)

Hits+Runs+RBIs

43g

avg 1.7

64.1%Over: 25-14-4

2vs O 0.5-185

Rays5/22

✓PP✓✗✓✗✗✓✓

H: 60%(20)A: 56.5%(23)

Singles

43g

avg 0.6

43.6%Over: 17-22-4

2vs O 0.5+115

Rays5/22

✓PP✗✗✓✗✗✓✗

H: 25%(20)A: 52.2%(23)

Walks

42g

avg 0.2

20.5%Over: 8-31-3

0vs O 0.5+228

Orioles5/11

P✓✓✗✗✗✗✓✗✓

H: 25%(20)A: 13.6%(22)

Inside Edge

Star Ratings

Avg Rating

3.4★★★★★

5-Star Games

4(10%)

Total Matchups

Distribution

Prop Performance by Star Rating

How Caballero's prop overs perform at the primary line based on InsideEdge hitter star rating

Stars	HitsO 0.5	RBIsO 0.5	Home RunsO 0.5
★★★★★	50%(2-2)	25%(1-3)	25%(1-3)
★★★★★	55.6%(10-8)	22.2%(4-14)	11.1%(2-16)
★★★★★	41.7%(5-7)	8.3%(1-11)	0%(0-12)
★★★★★	40%(2-3)	0%(0-5)	0%(0-5)
★★★★★	66.7%(2-1)	33.3%(1-2)	33.3%(1-2)

Recent Scouting Notes

★★★★★vs Trevor Rogers

5/12

Caballero is slugging .470 against left-handers over the last two years.

★★★★★vs Brandon Young

5/11

Matchup data is limited but favors Caballero.

★★★★★

5/10

Matchup data is limited but favors Caballero.

Game Log

Bet

260-952-119 Over1331 props

Date ↓	Opp	Market	Line	Actual	Result	Odds
5/22	vsRays	Doubles	O 0.5	0	L	+600
5/22	vsRays	Hits	O 1.5	2	W	+480
5/22	vsRays	Hits	O 0.5	2	W	-140
5/22	vsRays	Hits	O 2.5	2	L	+2700
5/22	vsRays	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 0.5	2	W	-185
5/22	vsRays	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 3.5	2	L	+750
5/22	vsRays	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 2.5	2	L	+350
5/22	vsRays	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 1.5	2	W	+155
5/22	vsRays	Home Runs	O 0.5	0	L	+1140
5/22	vsRays	Home Runs	O 1.5	0	L	+25000
5/22	vsRays	RBIs	O 0.5	0	L	+286
5/22	vsRays	RBIs	O 1.5	0	L	+1100
5/22	vsRays	Runs Scored	O 1.5	0	L	+2000
5/22	vsRays	Runs Scored	O 0.5	0	L	+220
5/22	vsRays	Singles	O 0.5	2	W	+115
5/22	vsRays	Stolen Bases	O 1.5	0	L	+1700
5/22	vsRays	Stolen Bases	O 0.5	0	L	+310
5/22	vsRays	Total Bases	O 1.5	2	W	+231
5/12	@Orioles	Hits	O 0.5	0	P	-155
5/12	@Orioles	Home Runs	O 0.5	0	P	+900
5/12	@Orioles	Hits	O 1.5	0	P	+360
5/12	@Orioles	Hits	O 2.5	0	P	+1700
5/12	@Orioles	Home Runs	O 1.5	0	P	+6000
5/12	@Orioles	Hits	O 3.5	0	P	+5000
5/12	@Orioles	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 4.5	0	P	+1000
5/12	@Orioles	Doubles	O 0.5	0	P	+425
5/12	@Orioles	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 3.5	0	P	+500
5/12	@Orioles	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 2.5	0	P	+270
5/12	@Orioles	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 0.5	0	P	-210
5/12	@Orioles	Hits+Runs+RBIs	O 1.5	0	P	+120
5/12	@Orioles	RBIs	O 4.5	0	P	+6000
5/12	@Orioles	RBIs	O 0.5	0	P	+250
5/12	@Orioles	RBIs	O 2.5	0	P	+2200
5/12	@Orioles	RBIs	O 3.5	0	P	+4000
5/12	@Orioles	RBIs	O 1.5	0	P	+850
5/12	@Orioles	Runs Scored	O 2.5	0	P	+4000
5/12	@Orioles	Runs Scored	O 1.5	0	P	+1000
5/12	@Orioles	Runs Scored	O 0.5	0	P	+165
5/12	@Orioles	Strikeouts	O 0.5	0	P	-210
5/12	@Orioles	Singles	O 0.5	0	P	+115
5/12	@Orioles	Total Bases	O 2.5	0	P	+425
5/12	@Orioles	Total Bases	O 1.5	0	P	+195
5/12	@Orioles	Total Bases	O 3.5	0	P	+675
5/12	@Orioles	Total Bases	O 0.5	0	P	-155
5/12	@Orioles	Total Bases	O 4.5	0	P	+1200
5/12	@Orioles	Singles	O 1.5	0	P	+760
5/11	@Orioles	Hits	O 1.5	0	P	+333
5/11	@Orioles	Doubles	O 0.5	0	P	+450
5/11	@Orioles	Hits	O 3.5	0	P	+4500
5/11	@Orioles	Hits	O 0.5	0	P	-165

New York Yankees Teammates

View all

Aaron Judge Jazz Chisholm Jr.Cody Bellinger Ben Rice Trent Grisham Austin Wells Ryan McMahon Paul Goldschmidt Giancarlo Stanton Amed Rosario J.C. Escarra Randal Grichuk Spencer Jones Jasson Domínguez Anthony Volpe

Frequently Asked Questions

How often does Jose Caballero hit the over on hits 0.5?

Jose Caballero hits the over on hits 0.5 57.5% of the time in 2026, going 23-17-4 with an average actual of 0.8. Based on $100 flat bets at best closing odds, this line has returned +$152.

How often does Jose Caballero hit the over on rbis 0.5?

Jose Caballero hits the over on rbis 0.5 20% of the time in 2026, going 8-32-4 with an average actual of 0.3. Based on $100 flat bets at best closing odds, this line has returned -$983.

How often does Jose Caballero hit the over on home runs 0.5?

Jose Caballero hits the over on home runs 0.5 10% of the time in 2026, going 4-36-4 with an average actual of 0.1. Based on $100 flat bets at best closing odds, this line has returned +$560.

How often does Jose Caballero hit the over on runs scored 0.5?

Jose Caballero hits the over on runs scored 0.5 37.5% of the time in 2026, going 15-25-4 with an average actual of 0.4. Based on $100 flat bets at best closing odds, this line has returned +$152.

How often does Jose Caballero hit the over on total bases 1.5?

Jose Caballero hits the over on total bases 1.5 37.5% of the time in 2026, going 15-25-4 with an average actual of 1.2. Based on $100 flat bets at best closing odds, this line has returned +$855.

What are Jose Caballero's best prop bets in 2026?

Jose Caballero's highest-hitting props in 2026: Hits+Runs+RBIs O 0.5 at 64.1% (25-14); Hits O 0.5 at 57.5% (23-17); Strikeouts O 0.5 at 56.4% (22-17).